The controversy began at KIPP Antioch College Prep, where teacher Eric Rivera was disciplined after declining to read Stella Brings the Family—a children’s book featuring a girl with two dads. Citing his religious beliefs, Rivera had arranged for a colleague to read the book instead. However, school administrators initially issued a ‘final warning,’ stating he must teach the curriculum with ‘fidelity’ or face termination.
Represented by the First Liberty Institute, Rivera argued that federal law requires religious accommodations in the workplace. This week, the school blinked, agreeing to clear Rivera’s record and formally allowing teachers to opt out of materials that conflict with their convictions.
While supporters call it a win for religious freedom, opponents worry this sets a concerning precedent. By allowing educators to physically step away from LGBTQ-inclusive curriculum, critics argue it sends a message to students that our families are ‘objectionable’ or something to be avoided. As Tennessee continues to navigate restrictive educational laws, this settlement marks a significant shift in how or if queer stories will be shared in classrooms.
